Tagging References
The publishing industry uses the words “citation” and
“reference” both interchangeably and in two rather different senses. One
meaning is a description of a work in a bibliography (bibliographic reference list). The
other is as a pointer to a description of a work in a bibliography. There is no consensus
on which word has which meaning, so this Tag Suite uses these (and other) bibliographic
reference terms in the following way:
Reference List (<ref-list>) | A list of bibliographic descriptions of material, for example, descriptions of
journal articles or books. The list typically has a title such as
“References”, “Bibliography”, or
“Additional Reading”. This Tag Set makes no distinction between
lists of cited references and lists of suggested references; both would be tagged
as <ref-list>. This Tag Library will
refer to these lists as references lists or as bibliographic references
lists. |
---|---|
Reference (<ref>) | One item in a bibliographic references list. Each item may be numbered, take a
prefix symbol, or a prefixed designator such as [Lapeyre 2009]. A <ref> is not a textual description of cited
material, but it may contain one or more such descriptions, or it may contain a
note. A very typical <ref> contains
the description of one work inside a citation element (<element-citation> or <mixed-citation>). A <ref> does not contain text
directly because some publishers place multiple works into a single numbered item
in a bibliographic reference list. The <ref> is the element for that item. Each cited work will be contained
in a citation element (<element-citation> or <mixed-citation>). |
Citation (<element-citation> or
<mixed-citation>) | The bibliographic description of a single work, such as a journal article.
This element will contain text, bibliographic elements, or a mixture of the two, for example, listing the title of a work, the
author, the date of publication, the page in the
journal on which the article starts, and similar information. Single citations are almost never numbered or given a prefix designator
because the prefix and identifying attribute are placed on the containing
<ref> element. But citations are
allowed to take numbers or designators (<label>) to handle those cases where a single item in a reference list
describes multiple works. |
Pointer | Inside the text of a work, it is common to refer to (cite) external sources
such as journal articles that were influential in forming the ideas expressed in
that part of the text. These too are commonly called “citations”.
This Tag Set will use the term cross-reference (the element <xref>) to name the text that points to the
description of a cited work in a bibliographic references list. The @ref-type on the <xref> can be set to “bibr” to
indicate that the cross-reference is pointing to an item in a reference list.
Typically, the @rid attribute will
point the unique identifier (@id) of
a <ref>. But when a <ref> contains multiple citations, the
@rid may point to the identifier
of a particular citation (<element-citation> or <mixed-citation>). |